AsiaCalling

Home News Timor Leste Timor’s Resistance Leadership under Fire

Timor’s Resistance Leadership under Fire

E-mail Print PDF

Download - Listen 

East Timorese have been marking ten years of independence from Indonesia.

It has not been an easy journey for the tiny nation.

More than half the population still lives on less than a dollar a day and unemployment is extremely high.

As Marianne Kearney reports from Dili while people have been celebrating the anniversary there is growing criticism that their independence heroes have not

done enough to improve everyday life.

Indonesian pop star, Krisdayanti speaks in Tetum to thousands of Timorese who have gathered to celebrate in front of Timor’s parliament.

Krisdayanti dances with Timor’s leaders, President Ramos Horta and Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao, to much applause.

She said Xanana the former guerilla leader, was even “more handsome in person” than his photos, and Krisdayanti called the two famous Timorese, her heroes.

On Dili’s streets Xanana and Ramos Horta are still popular heroes, much admired for roles in the 24 year long struggle for independence.

Today however many criticize them.

24-year-old student, Zaccarias Gutteres Sarmento, accuses the country’s leaders of being too pre-occupied with power.

“I think they focus too much on themselves, on their material well being, and don’t think about the ordinary people.”

Such comments would have been unthinkable back in 1999, and the early days of independence, when Xanana was viewed as a god-like figure who could do no wrong.

22-year-old student, Nato Ronaldo, says he still admires Xanana but is disappointed that has failed to solve many of the country’s problems.

“Fifty percent I agree with what they do, but fifty percent I doubt what they do, because the government hasn’t finished what they planned. For instance they haven’t built main roads, they haven’t helped the people enough.”

Arsenio Bano, a former student activist and member of the Fretilin opposition party says part of the problem, is that during the resistance years, Xanana Gusmao and Ramos Horta were treated as the people’s supreme commanders.

Timorese from guerillas to students all unquestioningly carried out their every whim.

“If they say go for demonstration, you do it because you do it for good things, you do it to contribute for the country to get independence, it doesn’t matter you get hurt or even sometimes you get killed, or got jailed no problem. We think doing a good thing for country is the best thing the student resistance can ever do.”

Fernando Borges, an independent member of parliament, says in the country there is still strong admiration for its resistance heroes.

However she says their years of being treated like gods has led to an undemocratic government.

“After 450 years of colonialisation and invasion, people are looking for change, what they’re saying is that they are seeing the same behaviours that were used in the past. Behaviours of authority, almost military-like. I tell you, you have to do this, I know best.”

Borges says Gusmao’s decision to free a former Indonesian militia leader last weekend is part of this autocratic style.

Martinus Bere who was arrested by Timorese police, was detained by a judge because he led a massacre in 1999 which 200 people were killed.

But Gusmao over-ruled the justice system, asking the prison authorities to free him and Bere was released to the Indonesian embassy on Sunday.

“Guerilla style leadership is based on very much military, very much dictatorship style, very much one person devising the strategy.”

Fretilin politician Bano says it is an insult to all the members of the resistance who sacrificed so much for Timor’s independence.

“Taking rule of law into their own hands is so, so insulting. Things change so quickly. This is people who tell us to demonstrate in time of resistance. This is a complete change when they say Timor doesn’t need justice.”

Bano is also critical of Ramos-Horta who said over the weekend that Timor needed development not human rights trials for the violations committed during the Indonesian period.

While many of Timorese are disillusioned with the leadership of the resistance heroes, some Timorese see more hope in the younger generation.

These are former student leaders and activists during the 1990’s, who are now politicians, ministers, or working for non-government groups.

19-year-old, Joao Baldwin admires Fernando Lasama, a former student activist, who was jailed by the Indonesians and now heads parliament.

“I think Fernando Lasama is a leader from the new generation. I like him because he is friendly, a socialist, and loves the people of East Timor.”

 

Last Updated ( Monday, 07 September 2009 10:40 )  

Add comment

Asia Calling House Rules for Comments:
We reserve the right to fail messages that:
· Are likely to provoke, attack or offend others
· Are racist, homophobic or sexists or otherwise objectionable
· Contain swear words or other language likely to offend
· Break the law or encourage illegal behavior
· Include contact details including number or email address
· Are considered to be advertising or promoting a product or SPAM
· Are considered off-topic


Security code
Refresh

 
      
 
  • This week on Asia Calling

Inside the women only zone in Afghanistan: This week in Asia Calling, we paid a visit to Kabul’s Women’s Garden, a state-run multi center where hundreds of Afghan women go to shop, work-out and learn new skills.....like driving Some say the eight-acre enclosure in the Shahrara neighborhood goes back to 1500s. More reliably it is dated to the 1940s or ’50s, when King Zahir Shah was said to have give it to the state. Three years ago it underwent a renovated with foreign aid money. Normally strictly a women’s only zone reporter Malyar Sadeq Azad was given permission to go inside for Asia Calling.

A Filipino who has taken part in 25 Easter crucifixions: On Good Friday– the holiest day of the year for Catholics- dozens of very devout followers in the Philippines re-enact the crucifixion of Jesus Christ. They nail their feet and hands nailed to wooden crosses, while others will flog themselves while walking barefoot through villages. The Philippines is Southeast Asia’s largest Roman Catholic nation. Madonna Virola meets one man who has carrying out this painful tradition for 25 years.

These stories and much more this week

on Asia Calling:

Your Window on Asia